Tuesday 31 August 2021

Why I should delete my personal blog

 It's been nearly fourteen years since I began this personal blog. Back then I remember it being mostly an outlet for what I was going through at the time, as a way to let others share in my experiences while I was trying to figure out my body and my place in the world as a then presumed intersex person. Above all it felt like a way to not feel so incredibly alone.

Until earlier that year, I had felt that keeping my struggles with being intersex and such a secret was the right thing to do. I didn't need to share it with anyone, because it simply was something you don't talk about. Of course, when a friend back then not only convinced me that it was nothing to be ashamed of, and proved it by dragging me in front of a (virtual) crowd of people, I found a level of acceptance and understanding that I had never thought possible.


When I look back on the many years of blog posts since that time, however, it's hard to be confronted with the thoughts which I wrote down back then, and the actions taken. With the benefit of hindsight, it's easy to see the spiral my life took, down the path of frustration and depression as I got nowhere with getting sensible answers from medical professionals. When I read those old posts, I am reminded of the frustrated attempts at trying to get answers, to get something changed for the better, only to always end up at rock bottom again.

It's not just the medical side either that's hard to read back. Clearly I had no idea or plan how to get out of this cycle, nor did I know what I really needed, or what would have made my life better. While it's easy to argue that I was obsessed with getting answers about my body, or even with getting answers I liked instead of accepting the 'gender dysphoria' and other diagnoses (e.g. autoparagynaecophilia) I did get handed, at the same time one could argue that it was reasonable to expect an honest attempt from medical professionals.

Especially for something as important to a person as the identity of one's body, as it didn't match the descriptions of male or female bodies, and this uncertainty fed back strongly into the uncertainty I felt about my identity and self-image.


The mean part about this psychiatric theory of gender dysphoria is probably how it flips biological reality upside-down. Rather than having the brain as the neutral element and the body as the element that is subject to certain levels of masculinisation, away from the default female phenotype, it assumes that the brain is what defines a person as either 'male' or 'female'. Because of the strongly held beliefs by the gender teams and other experts I consulted that the gender dysphoria and not the biological model was the appropriate one to use with an intersex person, my interest in learning more about my body was dismissed.

Who cares about what your body is like, when all that matters is what you feel it should be like?

Who cares about this 'intersex' thing, tell us whether you want to be male or female.

We can make you into a beautiful woman.


My body is now working its way through what I presume are the final stages of my long-delayed/extended puberty. I'm grappling with the realisation that my body was essentially female all along, and not male as it was assumed even by those specialists. What does this even mean for me? The most interesting realisation here is that I can still be myself, with any expectation of 'feeling' or 'behaving' in a male/female fashion being just ridiculous societal biases. This is a very liberating and empowering feeling.

Clearly, now that my body has gone off on its own like this and wrapped up a female-style puberty, even years after I stopped doing hormone therapy, I think that the question of whether I have an intersex body has been resolved. No thanks to medical healthcare professionals, sadly.


With that one reason for starting this blog has been basically resolved. All I have to do now is finish writing that autobiography and get it published and then I can move on. Easy peasy.


As for the 'not feeling so incredibly alone' part, I'm honestly not sure in how much this blog has contributed to resolving that. Part of me thinks that due to many of the things that I have written over the years, most likely I scared people away, rather than make them feel like I'd be a person they'd want to learn more about. Heck, I don't even like that person I see when I read back those old posts.

That makes me think that perhaps it is for the best if I were to archive this blog. Saving only a copy for my private perusal, to look up details while writing that part of my autobiography. Maybe this blog has served its purpose, if it ever had one.


Maya

4 comments:

Tom Farrier said...

I've always appreciated the insights you've offered in this blog. Your battles with medical "experts" illustrate how much objective realities have been forced through an essentially political prism over time. Your quote above is telling -- "Who cares what your body is like, when all that matters is what you feel it should be like? ... We can make you into a beautiful woman."

Having gotten to know you slowly, through your various writings, over a period of several years, I'm quite comfortable saying you're a beautiful person. If you prefer, it's equally easy to say you're a beautiful woman. Maybe it's best to say, "Maya is beautiful" and wirk from there.

Your blog has served a hugely important purpose for you, but it's an equally important way people gain gain an appreciation of *you.* Once your autobiography is finished, sure, it could be archived without taking that window into you away. Until then, it seems to be an ideal avenue for understanding who you are... and you're special, not just "unique."

No infatuation is at work here... just appreciation and admiration. 😊🤗

dlavie said...

Maya,
It is certainly your right to do what you will with your blog.
Your blog of your journey has inspired and educated others. And if you decided to leave it up, it would still do so.
Most of us in life start with a plan, desire or mission. Along the way things change,we discover other things and so the goal changes. It does not invalidate the journey or original plan.
Thank you for having been open and sharing this very personal journey.
Dave

Michael said...

Oh, the timing seems unlucky for me. I only recently I got comfortable with RSS/atom web feeds and got a setup going that I'm comfortable with, which resulted in me actively following some blogs. Yours I added a couple of days ago and this is only the second post that I read since then.

Before that, I only occasionally skimmed this blog. I think I met you first in person and only later I accidentally found your only presence and learned of your life story, which really touched me and resulted me in digging into your blog, even though it was just a day. Admitting this feels a bit awkward, since getting such private glimpses into someone's life seems almost voyeuristic, but I appreciated you sharing your story.

I'm looking forward to your biography and I guess I'll get some occasional glimpses into your life on other channels like twitter or whatever.

Cheers, Michael

Skin2279 said...

Remember where the "gender dysphoria" idea came from: it came from the John Money case. Before that, it was assumed that indeed it was the body that shaped the mind, not the other way round.

It seems to me that, in your case, the experts have learned the wrong lesson from this saga. They are assuming your brain must be either male or female, and so your body should be adapted to match. But of course your brain, like many others, has elements of both.